Did Jimmy Almost Date Nicole Kidman? A Funny Tale from The Tonight Show

On a memorable episode of The Tonight Show, Jimmy Fallon found himself reliving a surprisingly awkward encounter with one of Hollywood’s most beloved stars, Nicole Kidman. What started as a casual hangout quickly spiraled into a tale of miscommunication, cheese, and an unforgettable moment. Did Jimmy Fallon almost date Nicole Kidman? Let’s dive into this comedic story, which unfolded when they shared the stage on Jimmy’s late-night talk show.

A Chance Encounter with Nicole Kidman

The story begins years ago, when Jimmy was still hosting Saturday Night Live and Nicole Kidman was in the early stages of her iconic career. The events of that fateful day began with a phone call from a mutual friend, Rick, who seemed to have the ability to create dramatic moments out of thin air.

Rick called Jimmy while he was walking down the street in New York City and casually mentioned that Nicole Kidman was with him and wanted to meet Jimmy. According to Rick, it was potentially for a role in Bewitched or perhaps some other professional collaboration. This was, of course, before any romantic tension even entered the picture.

Jimmy, not one to shy away from an opportunity, agreed to meet Nicole. He was single at the time and figured it was simply a chance to meet a famous actress. However, what followed next was not what he expected.

The Cheese and Crackers Panic

Rick informed Jimmy that he was bringing Nicole to his apartment, but the situation immediately became more complicated. Jimmy, who had never prepared for a star-studded guest in his home, began to panic. “What do I do?” he asked Rick. “Do I have something? What do I do?”

Rick, perhaps trying to guide him through this celebrity encounter, suggested that Jimmy simply grab some cheese and crackers. However, Jimmy, not exactly a seasoned host for such an event, had no idea what to do. He didn’t keep dinner-party-worthy snacks like cheese and crackers at home. Instead, his place was stocked with video games and sneakers.

Panicking even more, Jimmy dashed into a deli to get some cheese. He was advised by Rick to pick up something like brie, though Jimmy was less than familiar with the finer details of cheese. “Brie? What is that?” Jimmy mused, clearly out of his depth in the world of high-class entertaining.

The Awkward Meeting

When Nicole Kidman arrived at Jimmy’s apartment, it quickly became clear that the situation was more awkward than either of them anticipated. Nicole, being the gracious star that she is, was probably just expecting a casual hangout. However, Jimmy—nervous and overwhelmed—was completely caught off guard.

As Nicole recalls, she found Jimmy wearing a baseball cap, with little else in terms of decor or conversation. She was there to meet a fellow Hollywood star, but all she found was an unusually quiet and shy Jimmy Fallon, who barely spoke. As the evening went on, the awkwardness continued to build.

Jimmy, who was likely flustered by the unexpected turn of events, tried to break the ice by putting on a video game. But this didn’t do much to thaw the tension between the two, and after about an hour and a half, Nicole Kidman decided there was no chemistry to be found here. “I thought, ‘He has no interest. This is so embarrassing,’” she confessed.

At that moment, she even considered the possibility that Jimmy might be gay, a thought that added another layer of confusion to the entire encounter.

Jimmy’s Perspective: Realizing the Missed Opportunity

From Jimmy’s perspective, the whole thing was a complete blur. He was oblivious to any romantic undertones, as he simply thought he was hosting a professional meeting with a movie star. In his mind, it was just a meeting about Bewitched—nothing more.

But, as Nicole recalls, the evening was a complete disaster. There was no spark, no chemistry, and no connection. As Nicole left, she was left wondering what went wrong. But for Jimmy, it was simply another awkward moment that he hadn’t quite understood until much later.

A Decade Later: Laughing About the Past

Fast forward to the present, and the two celebrities can look back on the situation with humor. During their conversation on The Tonight Show, both Jimmy and Nicole laughed about the awkwardness of the meeting. Nicole, now married to country music star Keith Urban, could joke about how things could have gone differently had there been more chemistry.

But despite the missed opportunity, both Jimmy and Nicole seem to have made the best decisions for themselves. Nicole found a lasting relationship with Keith Urban, and Jimmy, well, he’s gone on to become a beloved late-night host with a family of his own.

As Jimmy humorously reflected on the situation, “I can’t believe I dated Nicole Kidman!” to which Nicole quickly corrected him, saying, “You didn’t.” Still, both agreed that the chemistry was never there, but the comedy that came from the situation would live on forever.

The Fallout: Did Jimmy Make a Bad Decision?

In the years since that fateful evening, Jimmy’s fame and fortune have soared, and Nicole’s career has continued to flourish as well. They both went on to marry and have children, with Nicole now living happily in Nashville with Keith. As for Jimmy, he continues to host The Tonight Show and entertain millions of viewers around the world.

Despite the humorous regret they both share over the night, Nicole Kidman’s career and her marriage to Keith Urban have undoubtedly been much more fulfilling than any potential romance with Jimmy Fallon. And while Jimmy might have found his own place in the hearts of millions of fans, there’s no doubt that he looks back on that evening with a touch of embarrassment.

Looking Back with Laughter

At the end of the day, both Jimmy and Nicole can laugh at the awkwardness of their meeting, as it’s one of those moments that makes for great stories down the line. Though they never did date, their encounter will forever live in the comedic archives of The Tonight Show, reminding us all that even the stars have awkward moments.

And while we’ll never know what could have happened between Jimmy Fallon and Nicole Kidman, we can all agree that the comedic value of their story makes it one for the books.