Bills Mafia Outraged Over Josh Allen’s NFL Top 100 Ranking: A Disrespect to the 2025 MVP?

Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen has had an undeniably phenomenal 2024 season, yet fans—famously known as the Bills Mafia—are fuming over what they see as blatant disrespect: his ranking in the NFL’s Top 100 players list. Despite leading the Bills to the AFC Championship and capturing the league’s Most Valuable Player (MVP) award, Allen’s position on the list has stirred significant controversy. Many fans believe he was unjustly placed too low, especially considering the weight he carried throughout the season.

Josh Allen, who played his college football at the University of Wyoming, is no stranger to doubt or criticism. But even by his standards, being ranked below non-quarterbacks like Myles Garrett and Saquon Barkley—despite his historic performance—feels like a slight to not just him but the entire Bills organization.

Allen’s Season: A Historic Campaign

Let’s look at the numbers. In the 2024 NFL season, Allen threw for 3,731 yards and 28 passing touchdowns, while adding another 12 rushing touchdowns. That made it his fifth consecutive season with at least 40 total touchdowns, setting a new NFL record. His dual-threat capability was on full display all year, and in Week 14 against the Los Angeles Rams, Allen became the first player in NFL history to record three passing touchdowns and three rushing touchdowns in the same game. His offensive production was unprecedented, especially considering the lack of a consistent receiving corps compared to his AFC rivals.

Despite having to adjust to a rotating cast of wide receivers and a restructured offense under new offensive coordinator Joe Brady, Allen elevated his game and his team. The Bills’ march to the AFC Championship was no small feat, especially when other elite quarterbacks faltered or were surrounded by stronger support systems.

The Controversial Ranking

CBS Sports analyst Pete Prisco reportedly placed Allen at No. 4 in his Top 100 list, behind Patrick Mahomes, Myles Garrett, and Saquon Barkley. While Mahomes’ placement at the top doesn’t spark much debate—most would agree he remains the most valuable player in an open draft—ranking Allen behind two non-quarterbacks has raised eyebrows.

Fans quickly pointed out that while Barkley and Garrett had great seasons, the impact Allen had on his team far surpassed theirs. Barkley, who helped power the Eagles’ offense to a Super Bowl appearance, had a productive year, but many argue that a running back’s value pales in comparison to that of a franchise quarterback—especially one with MVP numbers and leadership that visibly lifted the entire franchise.

The choice to elevate Garrett and Barkley above Allen seemed even more questionable given Allen’s unique ability to dominate both through the air and on the ground. His versatility and clutch play in crucial moments were cornerstones of Buffalo’s deep playoff run. For many, the ranking came across not just as inaccurate, but insulting.

Bills Mafia: “Put Some Respect on Our QB”

The outrage wasn’t limited to sports media personalities or online analysts. The Bills Mafia, known for their fierce loyalty and passionate defense of their team, took to social media and radio talk shows to voice their disapproval. For them, Allen’s position wasn’t just about a number—it was about respect. Respect for his achievements, his leadership, and what he means to Buffalo.

“To put Allen behind a running back after he literally set league records and carried us through the playoffs is wild,” one fan wrote on X (formerly Twitter). “It’s like they didn’t even watch the games.”

Their frustration also stems from a perception that Allen is consistently underrated on the national stage, even when the stats and accolades speak for themselves. For many in Western New York and beyond, this year’s MVP was not just a testament to Allen’s talent, but to the perseverance of a franchise that has long waited for greatness—and now finally has it.

Allen Stays Humble, Focused on Bigger Goals

Interestingly, Josh Allen himself isn’t bothered by the slight. Speaking to Sports Illustrated after being named the 2024 MVP, Allen said, “It’s a great honor, but at the same time, I haven’t won a Super Bowl yet. I haven’t won a ring, and that’s the only goal.”

That mindset has endeared him even more to fans and teammates alike. While many players would use such a ranking as fuel for anger, Allen remains locked in on what matters most: winning a championship. His comments suggest that the MVP trophy, while significant, is secondary to team success and long-term legacy.

His offensive coordinator Joe Brady echoed that sentiment, saying, “The greatest gift for me was him winning the MVP, because I know how hard he works.” Brady credited Allen’s work ethic, resilience, and unwavering leadership as the reasons Buffalo stayed competitive all season long—even when injuries and inconsistency plagued other parts of the roster.

The Bigger Picture

Rankings like the NFL Top 100 are always subjective, and while they’re meant to recognize the best talent in the league, they often reflect personal biases and narratives more than hard data. Still, when a player like Josh Allen turns in a season for the history books, carries a team to the brink of the Super Bowl, and still gets edged out by players in less demanding roles, it’s bound to spark outrage.

It’s also worth noting that these rankings rarely affect players’ actual legacies—but they do shape public perception. For a city like Buffalo, where football is more than a sport, it’s a matter of civic pride. And right now, the city feels that pride has been disrespected.

Looking Ahead

Whether or not the ranking changes, one thing is clear: Josh Allen is among the NFL’s elite, and the league’s defenses know it. His combination of power, precision, and poise under pressure continues to evolve—and the rest of the NFL should take notice.

The Bills Mafia certainly has. And they’re ready to make sure the rest of the world sees exactly what their quarterback is made of.

As for Allen? He’ll let the wins—and hopefully a Lombardi Trophy—do the talking.