Tragedy in Akron: How a College Student’s Lies Ended in Murder

On March 3, 2020, the city of Akron, Ohio, became the backdrop for a chilling and tragic crime—one that no family ever imagines and no father could ever prepare for. Brenda Powell, a 50-year-old beloved mother and Akron Children’s Hospital employee, was found brutally murdered in her own kitchen. The initial story seemed to point to a violent home invasion, but investigators quickly uncovered a truth far more shocking: Brenda had been murdered by her own daughter, 19-year-old Sydney Powell.

The 911 Call That Changed Everything

At approximately 4:15 p.m., police responded to a 911 call placed by a college professor who had been on the phone with Brenda Powell moments before her death. During the call, the professor heard Brenda scream, and then the line went dead. When the professor called back, someone claiming to be Brenda answered—but the voice didn’t match. The professor suspected something was wrong and immediately contacted authorities.

When officers arrived at the Powell residence, they found a horrific scene. Brenda lay on the kitchen floor, barely clinging to life. She had suffered over 30 stab wounds to her neck and had also been struck on the head with a heavy iron skillet. The amount of blood in the room indicated the sheer brutality of the attack.

Sydney Powell was also found in the home. She had superficial injuries and appeared dazed, crying and claiming she had witnessed a break-in. She said an intruder had broken in through a window and attacked her mother. But as officers looked closer, her story began to unravel.

Cracks in Sydney’s Story

Investigators quickly noted inconsistencies in Sydney’s account. She claimed the intruder had come through a rear window, but the broken glass on the outside suggested it had been broken after the attack—not before. Blood spatter analysis supported that theory. Furthermore, the knife used in the attack was found near Brenda’s body, with no signs of an unknown attacker’s presence.

Adding to the suspicions was Sydney’s behavior. Despite her emotional state, she couldn’t explain what happened clearly. Her story shifted slightly each time she repeated it. She even claimed to have blacked out during the attack—an assertion she would later use as the foundation of her legal defense.

A Father’s Worst Nightmare

Steve Powell, Sydney’s father and Brenda’s husband, arrived at the scene unaware of the gravity of the situation. He had been alerted by university staff that a “distress call” had been made involving his daughter. When he tried calling Brenda and Sydney, neither answered their phones, and he began to fear the worst.

Even when he arrived, Steve did not know the full extent of the tragedy. He was informed that Brenda had been seriously injured, but not told she was on the brink of death. Nor did he realize that his own daughter was the primary suspect.

In police bodycam footage, Steve appears confused and heartbroken. He desperately tries to make sense of the scene while comforting his daughter—completely unaware that she may be responsible.

A Life of Lies

As detectives dug deeper into Sydney’s life, they discovered she had been hiding major secrets. She had been expelled from the University of Mount Union weeks before the incident but continued to lie to her parents, pretending everything was normal. Brenda, always supportive and involved in Sydney’s life, found out the truth the day of the murder and had called the school to speak with faculty.

The argument that followed between Brenda and Sydney may have been the final spark in what was already a firestorm of psychological stress. Sydney had struggled with anxiety and depression for years, though her friends said she always appeared happy on the surface.

Her former roommate, Lauren, told police that Sydney was directionless in college. She changed her major several times—starting with Exercise Science, switching to Psychology and Sociology, then to Education—all in search of something that never clicked. Sydney felt lost, anxious, and isolated. “She didn’t know what she wanted to do,” Lauren recalled. “She felt like everyone else had it figured out.”

The Insanity Defense

Once arrested, Sydney Powell told police she had no memory of the attack. Her attorneys would go on to argue that she suffered a psychological break and was not in control of her actions. She pled not guilty by reason of insanity, claiming that years of academic stress, mental health issues, and fear of disappointing her parents culminated in a violent blackout.

This presented a complex challenge for prosecutors. They had strong physical evidence tying Sydney to the crime but no clear motive beyond a psychological breakdown. The defense pushed for psychiatric evaluations to determine her mental state at the time of the murder.

The Trial and Aftermath

The case moved slowly through the legal system, delayed at times by pandemic-related court closures and the need for extensive psychological evaluation. Meanwhile, Brenda Powell’s friends and family were left grieving and confused, grappling with a tragedy that made no sense.

In court, the prosecution presented forensic evidence, phone records, and inconsistencies in Sydney’s statements. The defense emphasized her mental health and lack of criminal history. Her breakdown, they argued, was not premeditated but the result of long-term psychological suffering.

Ultimately, the court found Sydney Powell guilty of murder. She was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 15 years.

A Tragic Lesson

This case remains a haunting reminder of how unchecked mental health issues, combined with deception and fear, can lead to unimaginable outcomes. Sydney Powell was not a violent criminal by nature. She was a young woman overwhelmed by pressure, fear of failure, and perhaps untreated mental illness.

But no amount of stress can justify the brutal killing of a loving mother. Brenda Powell was a woman who had dedicated her life to helping children at the hospital, raising a daughter, and building a stable home. Her life was taken not by a stranger—but by the very person she tried to protect.

For Steve Powell, the pain of losing his wife is only compounded by the knowledge that his daughter is responsible. The emotional toll is beyond measure.

The Powell case forces us to ask hard questions: How can we better support young people under immense pressure? How do we detect when someone is at risk of breaking down? And how do we, as a society, prevent personal crises from becoming irreversible tragedies?

Full video: