Jon Stewart Dissects the Biden-Trump Debate: A Comic Tragedy of American Politics

On the latest episode of The Daily Show, Jon Stewart returned to his desk in fiery form to deliver what may be the most scathing — and hilarious — post-mortem of the Biden-Trump debate to date. With his signature mix of satirical brilliance and civic despair, Stewart turned 12 minutes of presidential chaos into a 30-minute comedy clinic — while laying bare the nation’s dismal political reality.

“We just watched what you watched,” Stewart opened. The audience’s laughter was immediate — and sympathetic. Because what America had just watched was not so much a debate as it was a live stress test for the American republic. It was also, Stewart suggested, a grim reminder that the bar for leadership in 2024 has been lowered to subterranean levels.

The Debate Day Hype

Before diving into the actual spectacle, Stewart skewered the media buildup — an endless countdown to “Debate Day in America.” Network anchors breathlessly ticked off hours like it was New Year’s Eve at Times Square. “Three days and counting. Two days. Just over 24 hours. Twelve and a half hours.” You’d think they were waiting for the moon landing, not two septuagenarians shouting over each other on national television.

As Stewart imagined it: “Old man Biden opening his window and shouting, ‘You there, boy! What day is today?’” To which America replies, “It’s debate day, sir!” A Dickensian tragedy — if Dickens wrote about cognitive decline and authoritarian cosplay.

The Expectations Game

Stewart highlighted the ludicrously low expectations both candidates were asked to meet.

For Trump: don’t be a fascist, don’t yell, don’t make fun of ethnic groups, and try to appear normal.

For Biden: stay awake, stay upright, don’t freeze, don’t mix up words. Literally, remain ambulatory.

Stewart: “Those are the same qualifications needed to be Scarecrow.” Not president, mind you — Scarecrow. The joke lands because it’s depressingly accurate. If we’re judging leadership by the ability to “stand there for an extended period of time,” then the winner might as well be a lamp post.

The Reality of the Debate

Once the debate began, Stewart gave both men the benefit of the doubt. “Level one cleared,” he joked as both walked onto stage without collapsing. But from there, it spiraled — fast.

Biden’s opening line — a halting, meandering sentence about COVID, Medicare, and possibly fighting Medicare (?) — instantly triggered a wave of dread among Democrats nationwide. “Need to call a real estate agent in New Zealand,” Stewart quipped.

And yet, things only got worse.

From one moment to the next, Biden lurched between issues, sometimes confusing healthcare with immigration, abortion with crime, and policy with tragedy. When he pivoted from Roe v. Wade to “a young woman who just was murdered… by an immigrant,” Stewart audibly winced. “Did you just immigration abortion?” he gasped, capturing the chaos in five perfect words.

Trump: The Asshole Test

If Biden’s task was to stay conscious, Trump’s was simpler: don’t be an asshole.

He failed immediately.

Whether calling Biden the worst president in history, bragging about his golf swing, or denying — again — that he had sex with a porn star, Trump didn’t just fail the asshole test. He seemed unaware the test existed. “Does not appear to have passed the asshole test,” Stewart concluded.

But that was just the warm-up.

Trump, true to form, unleashed a stream of self-congratulations, half-truths, and complete fabrications. The economy? “Best in history.” Veterans? “We did more than anyone.” COVID? “We got out of the mess.” Immigration? “Biden brought in millions of criminals.”

And then the clincher: “I didn’t have sex with a porn star.”

“Technically,” Stewart noted, “she was a porn character actor at best.”

The Moment That Could Have Mattered

There was one moment, Stewart observed, where things got real. Biden brought up the infamous quote attributed to Trump — that Americans who died in war were “losers” and “suckers.” Biden became visibly emotional talking about his son, Beau, a veteran. “My son was not a loser. He was not a sucker. You’re the sucker.”

It was raw, authentic, presidential.

Trump tried to deny he ever said it. “That’s a made-up quote,” he insisted.

To which Stewart responded: “A made-up quote, which in Trumpland means… it’s definitely a real quote.”

For a fleeting moment, Biden seemed like a real leader, speaking not as a politician but as a grieving father, honoring a national value. But even that moment passed too quickly.

“Let’s move to the topic of foreign policy,” the moderator said, as if what had just happened was an accidental fire drill rather than a defining moment of the debate.

So… Now What?

Stewart’s closing thought encapsulated the existential dilemma many Americans are now facing. “So Biden perhaps not on top of his game. Maybe I’ll check out this young upstart, Donald Trump,” he joked. But of course, Trump isn’t new, isn’t better, and isn’t normal.

And the third-party hopes? Stewart considered RFK Jr., only to back off when reminded that he’s an anti-vaccine conspiracy theorist with a running mate who believes in parasites and… other things best left off the air.

So where does that leave us?

“Do I take his car back to The White House tonight?” Stewart asked, mimicking Biden’s imminent eviction. “Do I just UPS his stuff?”

Because this, Stewart argued, was it. This was the moment — and we blew it.

The Verdict

The American electorate is now left choosing between two men who can barely string together coherent thoughts, both dragging decades of baggage, scandal, and cognitive fatigue behind them.

Jon Stewart doesn’t pretend to offer a solution. But what he does — better than anyone — is reflect our political absurdity back to us with piercing clarity. He takes the chaos, the horror, and the exhaustion — and makes us laugh, if only to keep from crying.

As Stewart said with deadpan sincerity: “Really makes you wonder what RFK Jr. is doing tonight.”

At this point, the bar is so low, it’s underground.

Full video: