1923 Cast & Character Guide

The star-studded cast of 1923 brings the characters of the second Yellowstone spinoff to life, with the ensemble boasting an incredible roster that includes Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren. Set in a dark time in the history of Montana, 1923 sees the Duttons struggling to keep their ranching empire afloat in the face of natural and man-made obstacles. Amid the Great Depression, Prohibition, a cattle theft epidemic, and other challenges, 1923 explores how the Duttons pulled through and established the largest contiguous cattle ranch in the U.S. when Yellowstone began.

Like 1883, 1923 adds many new characters to the Dutton family tree. Of course, the Dutton family is known for facing their share of enemies, and the 1923 cast also includes some of the most memorable villains in the franchise to date. Some characters in 1923 are more-or-less disconnected from the future of the Dutton ranch, too, and have their own stories showing the hardships other people and cultures faced during this brutal era of American history. All 1923 characters combine to add to the sweeping and rich Western story, with an impeccably well-selected cast.

Actors
Characters

Harrison Ford
Jacob Dutton

Helen Mirren
Cara Dutton

Brandon Sklenar
Spencer Dutton

Darren Mann
Jack Dutton

Michelle Randolph
Elizabeth Strafford

James Badge Jr.
John Dutton Sr

Marley Shelton
Emma Dutton

Brian Geraghty
Zane Davis

Aminah Nieves
Teonna

Julia Schlaepfer
Alexandra

Jerome Flynn
Banner Creighton

Timothy Dalton
Donald Whitfield

Jennifer Carpenter
Mamie Fossett

Augustus Prew
Paul

Janet Montgomery
Hillary

Jacob Dutton

Played By Harrison Ford

Character: Jacob Dutton is played by Harrison Ford in 1923. Jacob took over the ranch after the deaths of Yellowstone Dutton Ranch founders, 1883‘s Margaret (Faith Hill) and James Dutton (Tim McGraw). Apart from turning the ranch into a small empire, Jacob and his wife, Cara Dutton, raised James and Margaret’s kids, Spencer and John Dutton Sr., as their own. Though he is weakened by an early assassination attempt in the series, Jacob remains the strong center of the Dutton family and the one they all look to for guidance.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

Star Wars (1977)
Han Solo

Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981)
Indiana Jones

Blade Runner (1982)
Rick Deckard

The Fugitive (1993)
Richard Kimble

Air Force One (1997)
President James Marshall

Actor: 1923 cast member Harrison Ford is one of Hollywood’s most iconic actors. He became a household name with his breakout role as Han Solo in Star Wars and cemented that status with the Indian Jones franchise. Beyond his two most beloved franchises, Ford has starred in Blade Runner, The Fugitive, Air Force One, and Witness, for which he was nominated for an Oscar. He joined the Marvel Cinematic Universe in 2025 as Thunderbolt Ross/The Red Hulk in Captain America: Brave New World.

Cara Dutton

Played By Helen Mirren

Character: Harrison Ford is joined in the 1923 cast by Helen Mirren as Cara Dutton, and there’s a reason why Jacob refers to his wife Cara as “the boss.” While Jacob leads the ranch’s cowboys, Cara is in charge of the day-to-day operations on the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch. When her family is attacked, Cara steps up to take control, fight back against their enemies, and continue to protect her loved ones at any cost.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

The Madness of King George (1994)
Queen Charlotte

Gosford Park (2001)
Mrs. Wilson

The Queen (2006)
Queen Elizabeth II

The Fate of the Furious (2017)
Magdalene Shaw

Barbie (2023)
Narrator

Actor: A screen veteran with over 100 movies and series under her belt prior to joining the cast of 1923, Dame Helen Mirren won an Oscar for The Queen and received nominations for The Madness of King George, Gosford Park, and The Last Station. Mirren has also appeared in The Long Good Friday, Shazam!: Fury of the Gods, and was recently part of the cast of Fast X as well as narrator of Barbie.

Spencer Dutton

Played By Brandon Sklenar

Character: Spencer is the youngest son of James and Margaret Dutton, and is played in the 1923 cast by Brandon Sklenar. After fighting in the Great War, Spencer Dutton moved to Namibia to become a successful hunter. The first season of 1923 follows Spencer’s perilous journey back home after learning about the dire situation he finds himself in. It remains to be seen how quickly Spencer makes it home in season 2 of 1923.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

Vice (2018)
Bobby Prentace

Midway (2019)
George Gay

The Offer (2022)
Burt Reynolds

It Ends With Us (2024)
Atlas Corrigan

Actor: Actor Brandon Sklenar is a relative newcomer who has certainly found his breakout role in 1923. He had a small but memorable appearance in the limited series The Offer as Burt Reynolds. He has also had small roles in Adam McKay’s Oscar-winning Vice and the World War II movie Midway. Most recently, he starred alongside Blake Lively in It Ends with Us in 2024.

Jack Dutton

Played By Darren Mann

Character: The fiery Jack Dutton, played in the 1923 cast by Darren Mann, is the son of Emma and John Dutton Sr. He is a dedicated cowboy who is set to marry his fiancée, Elizabeth. Notably, Jack is the only member of the third generation of Yellowstone‘s Duttons in 1923. He has a youthful arrogance that makes him feel invincible, but he is also smart enough to stop and listen to the more experienced relatives around him.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina (2018-2020)
Luke Chalfant

Animal Kingdom (2016-2022)
Young Baz

The Minute You Wake Up Dead (2022)
Lucius

Breakwater (2023)
Dovey

Actor: Canadian actor Darren Mann is another newcomer who looks to have a bright career ahead of him. Before 1923, Mann had memorable roles as Baz in season 6 of Animal Kingdom and Luke Chalfant in Chilling Adventures of Sabrina. He also appeared opposite Oscar winner Morgan Freeman in the thriller The Minute You Wake Up Dead in 2022.

Elizabeth Strafford

Played By Michelle Randolph

Character: Elizabeth Strafford is dead-set on marrying Jack Dutton, even though he seems more interested in herding cattle than marriage. Nonetheless, Jack and Emma’s relationship is a crucial chapter in the ranch’s history and could reveal more about the Yellowstone timeline and how 1923‘s Duttons are connected to Yellowstone‘s first family. Though she comes from a family very different from the Duttons, she chooses to stay with them rather than flee once the violence begins.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

House of the Witch (2017)
Rachel

A Snow White Christmas (2018)
Bianca Snow

Landman (2024)
Ainsley Norris

Actor: 1923 cast Michelle Randolph as Elizabeth, a decision that worked well for the series. A relative newcomer to the screen, Randolph also appears in House of the Witch and A Snow White Christmas. She also joined another Taylor Sheridan series with Landman opposite Billy Bob Thorton, Demi Moore, and Jon Hamm, where she plays Tommy and Angela’s strong-willed daughter and Cooper’s sister.

John Dutton Sr.

Played By James Badge Dale

Character: Spencer’s big brother, John Dutton Sr., is the eldest son of James and Margaret Dutton. He is portrayed in the cast of 1923 by James Badge Dale. John, who was just a little boy in 1883, grew up to be a capable cowboy in 1923 and a good father to Jack. Sadly, he is an early casualty in 1923, as John is killed when Banner Creighton and his men ambush the Duttons.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

24 (2002-2003)
Chase Edmunds

The Pacific (2010)
Robert Leckie

The Departed (2006)
Barrigan

World War Z (2013)
Captain Seke

Iron Man 3 (2013)
Savin

Actor: James Badge Dale is an actor who has had an impressive career in both movies and television. After getting his start on shows like 24 (where he played Chase Edmunds), Dale appeared in films like the MCU’s Iron Man 3, Brad Pitt’s horror movie World War Z, and the Oscar-winning Martin Scorsese crime movie The Departed. One of his most prominent roles was in the cast of The Pacific as Robert Leckie. He also starred as Ray Abruzzo in Hightown from 2020 to 2024.

Emma Dutton

Played By Marley Shelton

Character: Marley Shelton’s 1923 character Emma Dutton is the wife of John Dutton Sr. and the mother of Jack. Emma also assists Cara in running the ranch when the cowboys are away. Following John’s death, Emma falls into a deep depression and struggles to find a reason to carry on. She’s a character who highlights the loss the Dutton family suffers throughout their legacy in America. The final few episodes of 1923 season 1 show how the family also has to contend with the harsh realities of their lifestyle as she pulls herself together.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

Sin City (2005)
The Customer

Grindhouse (2007)
Dakota Block

W. (2008)
Fran

A Perfect Getaway (2009)
Cleo

Scream 4 (2011)
Judy Hicks

Actor: Actor Marley Shelton is a notable horror movie actor with roles in Grindhouse, The Perfect Getaway, and in the Scream franchise as Judy Hicks. She also appeared in Dwayne Johnson’s adventure movie Rampage, Oliver Stone’s W, and Sin City. On television, she had leading roles in shows like Rise (Gail Mazzuchelli), The Lottery (Alison Lennon), and Eleventh Hour (Rachel Young).

Zane Davis

Played By Brian Geraghty

Character: Similar to Rip Wheeler on Yellowstone, Zane is a loyal ranch hand who works at the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch. Although Brian Geraghty’s 1923 character is not a Dutton, he acts and is treated as though he’s part of the family, implying he’s been working at the ranch for years. Outside the ranch, Zane is a family man who lives a peaceful life with his wife and children, but he becomes targeted by the enemies of the Dutton family.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

Jarhead (2005)
Private First Class Fergus O’Donnell

The Hurt Locker (2009)
Owen Eldridge

Chicago PD (2014-2020)
Sean Roman

The Fugitive (2020)
Colin Murphy

Big Sky (2020-2022)
Ronald Pergman

Actor: Brian Geraghty starred in the Best Picture winner The Hurt Locker, played opposite Denzel Washington in Flight, and was in Sam Mendes’ Jarhead. He has appeared as Sean Roman in all three of the One Chicago series. Geraghty has recently had notable television roles as Ronald Pergman in Big Sky and Colin Murphy in The Fugitive. Other than 1923, Geraghty also had a recurring role in Gaslit as Peter and in Big Sky as Ronald Pergman.

Teonna

Played By Aminah Nieves

Character: While fans knew the series would focus on a new generation of the Dutton family, many were unprepared for 1923‘s most shocking storyline based of real events. Teonna, played by Aminah Nieves, is an Indigenous American stuck in a Catholic boarding school where she suffers abuse from nuns and priests. Much of the season deals with her escape and fight for freedom as her sadistic abusers hunt her.

Conversations around Teonna hint that she could be related to Yellowstone‘s Thomas Rainwater, chief of the Confederated Tribes of Broken Rock and that her fate in 1923 will reveal more about Thomas’s family history.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

Blueberry (2021)
Elsa

V/H/S/99 (2022)
Charissa

Actor: Cast member Aminah Nieves is still early in her career, with her only notable appearance before 1923 being in Blueberry. In the same year she debuted in 1923, Nieves appeared in a segment in the horror anthology movie V/H/S/99. After 1923, she mostly starred in short films like Volition (2023) and The Demon and Dumbo (2024), but she has a role in an upcoming Kathryn Bigelow White House thriller that is in production.

Alexandra

Played By Julia Schlaepfer

Character: Alexandra, played by Julia Schlaepfer, is a woman who meets Spencer Dutton abroad. As a rich and affluent woman engaged to someone in her own class, Alexandra and Spencer seem like they are from two different worlds. However, they quickly form a bond, with Alexandra leaving her fiancé for Spencer and joining him on his journey back to the Yellowstone ranch.

Alexandra is taken out of her comfort zone during her travels with Spencer as she encounters one danger after another. However, with each harrowing experience she encounters, her love for Spencer becomes clearer.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

Madam Secretary (2017)
Ashley Whittaker

The Politician (2019-2020)
Alice Charles

Charlie Says (2018)
Sandra Good

The Sky Is Everywhere (2022)
Rachel Brazile

Actor: American actor Julia Schlaepfer is probably best known for playing the character of Alice Charles in Netflix’s comedy-drama The Politician opposite Gwyneth Paltrow and Ben Platt. Her career has been largely focused on television projects, with appearances in Madam Secretary and American Horror Stories. She also appeared in the Manson Family movie Charlie Says, which starred Matt Smith as Manson.

Banner Creighton

Played By Jerome Flynn

Character: Portrayed in another captivating performance by Jerome Flynn, 1923‘s Banner Creighton is an immigrant and sheepherder who is fighting with the local ranchers for grasslands. In Paradise Valley, Banner is one of the few people willing to butt heads with Jacob and Cara. When he decides to take more drastic measures against his new enemies, Banner finds some powerful allies who also want to see the Duttons removed from the land.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

Game of Thrones (2011-2019)
Bronn

Black Mirror (2016)
Hector

John Wick: Chapter 3 (2019)
Berrada

Loving Vincent (2017)
Dr. Gachet

Actor: English actor Jerome Flynn is best known for playing Bronn, the nefarious yet likable sellsword who formed a bond with Tyrion Lannister and his brother Jaime, in Game of Thrones. Flynn also appeared as villain Berrada in John Wick: Chapter 3 – Parabellum, the Oscar-nominated animated movie Loving Vincent, and was in the Black Mirror season 3 episode, “Shut Up and Dance.”

Donald Whitfield

Played By Timothy Dalton

He is a man who is after power by any means

Character: As 1923 is a story about the Duttons, it wouldn’t be complete without a villain tough enough to take on this family, which is where Donald Whitfield comes in. Donald is a foreign land developer seeking to take over not just the Dutton ranch, but the entire valley — with a little help from Banner Creighton. He is a man who is after power by any means and shows how greed gives way to some more sadistic habits as well. This only adds to his chilling villainous presence in the show.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

License to Kill (1989)
James Bond

The Rocketeer (1991)
Neville Sinclair

Hot Fuzz (2007)
Simon Skinner

Doom Patrol (2019-2021)
Chief

Actor: Younger 1923 audiences may know Timothy Dalton from Doom Patrol, Penny Dreadful, and The Crown. However, in the world of cinema, Dalton is best known for playing James Bond in The Living Daylights and License to Kill. He has also appeared in The Rocketeer, Hot Fuzz, and the Toy Story franchise as Mr. Pricklepants.

Mamie Fossett

Played By Jennifer Carpenter

Character: Jennifer Carpenter joins the 1923 cast in its second season as a character named Mamie Fossett. Carpenter plays Marnie Fossett, a highly-skilled U.S. Deputy Marshall who serves warrants and makes arrests with confidence ahead of her time. “She had intended to homestead in the area and became one of the first female U.S. Marshals,” Carpenter said (via TV Fanatic). “Not to do clerical work behind a desk, but to go and work the territory.”

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

The Exorcism of Emily Rose (2005)
Emily Rose

Dexter (2006-2013)
Debra Morgan

Limitless (2015-2016)
Rebecca Harris

The Enemy Within (2019)
Erica Shepherd

Actor: Jennifer Carpenter has been acting since college and had early work on Broadway after attending Julliard School. She got her mainstream break when she appeared in the titular role in the Scott Derrickson horror movie The Exorcism of Emily Rose. However, the biggest role of her career came a year later when she signed on to star as Debra Morgan in Dexter on Showtime, a lead role that she carried through most of the series.

Paul

Played By Augustus Prew

Character: Augustus Prew joins the 1923 cast in the second season as Paul, a “dapper, bookish, well-to-do young British man on a passenger ship.” There is little information about what his character will do in the series.

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

Kick-Ass 2 (2013)
Todd Haynes/Ass-Kicker

Pure Genius (2016-2017)
James Bell

The Morning Show (2019-present)
Sean

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (2022)
Médhor

Actor: Augustus Prew has been an actor since 2001 and has worked on both television and big-screen films. His first television role came in 2001 when he starred in the British series 24Seven as Drew Jessup. He then had a role in the popular Hugh Grant movie About a Boy. One of his bigger roles came in 2013 when he replaced Evan Peters as Todd Haynes in Kick-Ass 2. He also had the lead role in the TV series Pure Genius and most recently appeared in The Morning Show and The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power.

Hillary

Played By Janet Montgomery

Character: Janet Montgomery joins the cast of 1923 in the second season as Hillary, a “thoughtful woman who longs for justice.” Hillary will be someone who does not want to see injustice go unpunished. “Forever grateful for every opportunity I get to do what I love. Pinching myself over this one,” Montgomery said (via Instagram).

Notable Movies & TV Shows:

Title
Role

Salem (2014-2017)
Mary Sibley

This is Us (2016-2017)
Olivia Maine

New Amsterdam (2018-2023)
Dr. Lauren Bloom

The Ex-Wife (2022)
Jen

Actor: Janet Montgomery is an English actress who starred in several big movies, including Black Swan and Our Idiot Brother. She was also in another Paramount+ show, where she played Jen in The Ex-Wife. She also had lead roles in several other TV shows, including New Amsterdam (2018-2023), This is Us (2016-2017), Salem (2014-2017), and Human Target (2010-2011).

Rate Now