As American Idol Season 23 approaches its semifinals on May 10 and 11, 2025, anticipation is building around which contestants will secure a spot in the coveted Top 3. Based on recent performances, audience engagement, and insights from industry professionals, here are the leading contenders:

Predicted Top 3 Finalists

1. John Foster

At just 18 years old, John Foster has emerged as a frontrunner with his neo-traditional country style. His performances have consistently resonated with audiences, evident from his rendition of “I Told You So,” which garnered over 7 million views on Facebook . Judges have praised his vocal tone and stage presence, positioning him as a strong candidate for the finale.

2. Jamal Roberts

Advertisements

Ezoic

Jamal Roberts stands out with his versatility and dynamic performances. His soulful rendition of “Heal” showcased his emotional depth, earning him nearly 2 million views on Facebook . Judges have highlighted his ability to connect with the audience, making him a likely finalist.

3. Gabby Samone

Advertisements

Ezoic

Gabby Samone has captivated both judges and viewers with her powerful vocals and stage charisma. Her performance of “A Song for You” received 2.5 million views on Facebook . Her consistent growth and adaptability across genres suggest she has a strong chance of reaching the Top 3

Audience Engagement & Performance Metrics

Recent Facebook viewership statistics for the Top 12 performances indicate strong audience support for these contestants:

John Foster: 7.1 million views

Gabby Samone: 2.5 million views

Jamal Roberts: 1.9 million views

These numbers reflect not only their popularity but also their ability to engage and connect with a broad audience.

Upcoming Semifinals & Voting Information

The semifinals will air live on ABC:

Sunday, May 10, 2025

Monday, May 11, 2025

Viewers can cast their votes through the official American Idol app, website, or via text. Voting opens at the start of each live show and closes shortly after the final performance.

Final Thoughts

While John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Gabby Samone are leading the predictions, American Idol is known for its surprises. Other contestants like Breanna Nix, Slater Nalley, Thunderstorm Artis, and Mattie Pruitt have also delivered noteworthy performances and could upset the current projections.

Ezoic

Stay tuned for the semifinals to see which talented artists will make it to the finale!

Note: This article is based on available performance data and audience engagement metrics as of May 9, 2025. Actual results may vary.