Extreme Isolation Meets High Stakes: Greg Gutfeld’s New Game Show Explores Fake News and Real Consequences

In today’s world, where the line between real and fake news often seems blurred, the quest for truth has never been more intense. In Greg Gutfeld’s new Fox Nation game show, What Did I Miss?, contestants are pushed to their limits as they compete for a grand prize of $50,000 by guessing which headlines from President Trump’s first 100 days back in the White House are true and which are fabrications. The extreme measures taken to prepare these contestants for the game, including isolating them from the outside world for months, highlight the show’s unique approach to a timeless question: Can people really tell fact from fiction?

The format of the show is deceptively simple. Contestants are tasked with distinguishing between real and fake news stories, but the method used to prepare them is anything but ordinary. As detailed in a promotional clip shared with TheWrap, the contestants are isolated in a remote farmhouse in upstate New York—far from the digital noise of modern life. No cell phones, no internet, and no access to the news for weeks. Their only company is each other, and their days are filled with activities like weightlifting and reading books. This seclusion creates an environment that is as unsettling as it is intriguing, with Gutfeld humorously noting that it’s not for any “kinky Epstein stuff”—just the opportunity to win a substantial sum of money.

The setup offers a stark contrast to the hyper-connected world many of us live in today, where news and social media can be consumed constantly. In a society dominated by digital information, the game challenges contestants to rely solely on their own wits and recall of events from President Trump’s first three months back in the White House. Gutfeld’s decision to lock contestants away from any external influences reflects the growing tension between reality and the often manipulated narratives that circulate in the media.

Adding to the intrigue, contestants are not only isolated in a farmhouse but also subjected to further sensory deprivation on their way to the show’s headquarters in New York City. The contestants are blindfolded and wear noise-canceling headphones during the bus ride, ensuring that no accidental spoilers seep in. This intense approach heightens the stakes, giving viewers a glimpse into the contestants’ emotional states as they grapple with their isolated existence.

Once the contestants arrive in New York, they are bombarded with a series of real and fake headlines, often bizarre and outlandish, like whether rapper Ye attended the 2025 Grammys naked. Their task is to sift through this mixture and identify which headlines are authentic. The one who proves most adept at distinguishing fact from fiction will walk away with $50,000, but the prize is more than just a cash reward—it also promises the ultimate social media re-entry: the opportunity to once again access Instagram after months without it.

This blend of humor and tension makes What Did I Miss? a compelling show. Gutfeld, known for his late-night commentary, brings a lighthearted touch to what could be a heavy subject, with comedic relief provided by regulars Jamie Lissow and Kat Timpf. Timpf, in particular, adds an emotional layer to the show, having made her return to television after a difficult period of dealing with a breast cancer diagnosis while giving birth to her son. Her presence on the show provides a poignant reminder of the resilience of the human spirit, even in the face of life’s most challenging moments.

The show’s three-episode run, set to premiere on May 12, promises to keep audiences on the edge of their seats. As Gutfeld guides viewers through the strange world of isolated contestants attempting to navigate a sea of falsehoods, What Did I Miss? offers more than just entertainment—it raises important questions about how we engage with news in the modern world. Can we still trust what we read? And, more importantly, how do we know when something is fake?

In a media landscape increasingly dominated by confusion and sensationalism, Gutfeld’s show might just be the antidote we need—a reminder of the importance of questioning what we hear and the lengths some will go to in search of truth. With its mix of humor, tension, and real-world stakes, What Did I Miss? could be the perfect blend of entertainment and critical thinking for today’s audience.