John Mulaney vs. The Teens: Comedy, Chaos, and Core Strength on The Daily Show

John Mulaney has always blurred the line between highbrow wit and absurdist comedy, and his appearance on The Daily Show with Jon Stewart was a masterclass in both. Ostensibly there to promote his Netflix show Everybody’s in L.A., the conversation quickly devolved — or evolved — into a sprawling, hilarious tale of Mulaney fighting three 14-year-olds on live television. And yes, it was somehow both literal and metaphorical.

The bit, which took up nearly the entire interview, revolved around the climactic final episode of Everybody’s in L.A., a surrealist talk show that aired over 12 nights during Netflix’s “Netflix is a Joke” festival. In the show’s finale, Mulaney physically wrestled three teenage boys — Jacob, Ben, and Adarsh — in a carefully regulated match (no punching, no eye gouging, “advanced hugging and wrestling only”) that mirrored an amateur MMA bout with a strange layer of social commentary.

Stewart, serving as the amused elder statesman of comedy, was incredulous but delighted. He asked pointed questions like, “Did you fly them in across state lines?” and marveled at the logistical and legal hoops Mulaney had apparently leapt through to make his teenage fight club a reality. Mulaney, in turn, waxed poetic about the value of ritual combat with adolescents — not as a stunt, but as a metaphor for the male crisis of identity and physicality in a screen-addicted, testosterone-fueled age.

“Everyone should fight three teenagers once a year,” Mulaney deadpanned. “You’ll feel invigorated.”

In typical Mulaney fashion, the joke teetered between absurd and sincere. The narrative had the loose, sprawling feel of a late-night fever dream, but underneath the silliness were serious themes: aging, masculinity, generational disconnection, and vulnerability. Mulaney spoke with mock-heroism about how the boys formed a “three-boy monster,” learning mid-fight to work together like the Borg, slowly overwhelming him despite his carefully laid plans.

“I knew I had to keep moving. Once I slowed down, they adapted.”

The beauty of this longform bit is its operatic commitment to the absurd. Mulaney described each teen like a character in The Iliad, with Adarsh going “silverback” after the match and Jacob being identified early as the biggest threat. He spoke of strategy — “go at Jacob early” — and physical limitations — “they don’t have core strength, but I do, because I have a tear in my hip.” What started as a silly story turned into a deconstructed sports commentary, a parenting anecdote, and even a masculine identity crisis all in one.

Stewart, for his part, was the perfect foil: amazed, occasionally skeptical, but ultimately on board for the entire ride. At one point, he compared Mulaney’s efforts to the Roosevelt quote about “the man in the arena,” which Mulaney quickly connected to the cliché of people sending that quote when your career is in crisis — “I had a sitcom that was shot out of the air like a duck in Duck Hunt,” he recalled.

But what made the moment extra surreal was the appearance of celebrity cameos within the story. According to Mulaney, Adam Sandler was standing by the ring as a pseudo-cornerman while Sean Penn — ever the cinematic wild card — smoked calmly nearby, watching the chaos unfold. Mulaney joked that Penn “looked like he sleeps in a meat dehydrator” and imagined him pulling a Temple of Doom-style heart removal on a 14-year-old if he’d been in the ring instead.

The conversation also managed to reflect on fatherhood. Mulaney referenced his own toddler son, who playfully (or perhaps ominously) tries to poke his father’s eyes during playfights. Stewart followed with a heartfelt — and funny — story about his own son beating him in arm wrestling, marking a shift in their power dynamic and his own awareness of aging. It was a moment of real generational reckoning wrapped in laughter.

This entire segment felt like a reinvigoration of the talk show format: two seasoned comics going completely off-script, finding comedy in chaos, and making viewers feel like they were witnessing something personal and unrepeatable. While many late-night shows rely on over-rehearsed bits and sanitized anecdotes, this was unfiltered, unpredictable, and brilliantly entertaining.

The closing segment of the interview turned into a game — Stewart read past questions he’d asked famous guests and challenged Mulaney to guess who they were directed at. The resulting exchanges — from Desmond Tutu to Malala Yousafzai to Jane Goodall — were an exercise in chaos theory comedy. It was as though The Daily Show had merged with a fever dream episode of Between Two Ferns, and it worked beautifully.

What this appearance ultimately reaffirmed is that John Mulaney is not just a stand-up comic or writer — he is a comedy performance artist, willing to turn his own body and career into the canvas. Whether he’s confessing to past addiction, parenting, or bizarre brawls with teens, he commits fully, inviting the audience to laugh at the surreal theatre of life.

As Stewart said in closing, “You are the man in the arena — literally.” And in this moment, that arena was a wrestling mat, a talk show desk, and the collective imagination of anyone who watched Mulaney go full tilt into the chaos.

Full Video: