‘American Idol’ Runner-up John Foster Breaks His Silence on Finale Rumors

American Idol season 23 is officially over, and Jamal Roberts is the show’s 2025 winner. But some fans seem to think someone already knew about his victory… namely the person standing right next to him when it was announced.

Jamal and John Foster were the final two contestants in the running during the finale on May 18, and host Ryan Seacrest had them stand beside one another as he revealed this year’s American Idol. The camera panned between John and Jamal, and fans watched as the two waited to hear which name would be called out. When Jamal was declared the winner, John seemed calm and collected in reaction to the result.

“@officialjamalroberts WINS #AmericanIdol!!! ,” the caption read when American Idol posted the moment on Instagram.

While fans were thrilled about Jamal’s win, many noticed the camera pick up a key detail about John’s American Idol loss. They noticed he appeared to have a good view of the envelope Ryan held onstage… and the name that was written on the card within it.

“You can see when John Foster looks over and sees that he’s not the winner! Just look at his reaction! John you were great! Don’t give up on your dream! Keep singing ,” one person wrote in the comments. “John saw the name on the card. That must have been tough ,” another noted. “John peeped They were all so SO good!! ,” a different follower added.

So, did John truly take a look at whose name was on the card? As he explained to TV Insider, he wasn’t even paying attention to what had been written down as the finale occurred.

“I was in a total blur,” he stated to the outlet. “I knew I was at peace with being runner-up. Jamal is such an incredible performer. I was at peace. I really was. It’s a true honor to be runner-up.”

John certainly appeared to be alright with the result, as he later went on Instagram to reflect on his experience being on American Idol.

“Man, what a true blessing to share this Idol stage with so many incredible heroes, both new faces and legends,” he wrote in the caption. “I’m beyond thankful, and I can’t wait to keep making music for y’all as long as the good Lord lets me. Thank you from the bottom of my heart – times a million. .”

READ MORE :

Ryan Seacrest’s Surprise Engagement and Wedding Location Revealed — You Won’t Believe Who the Bride Is and Where They’re Tying the Knot!

Ryan Seacrest, the iconic American TV and radio personality, has been keeping his personal life tightly under wraps since his split with Aubrey Paige in 2024. But as we enter 2025, the 50-year-old American Idol legend is stirring up a storm of gossip, and this time, it’s not just about his career. Word is out: Ryan Seacrest is engaged—and the mystery woman who has captured his heart is a true bombshell.

Sources close to Seacrest have confirmed that, as of April 8, 2025, the long-time Live with Kelly and Ryan host is ready to walk down the aisle. However, the big question everyone is asking is: Who is the bride? According to insiders, Ryan’s engagement is one of Hollywood’s best-kept secrets—and trust us, it’s one that has shocked even the most loyal Seacrest fans.

While Ryan has been notoriously private about his romantic life in recent years, this new chapter in his personal story has people talking. His past relationships, including high-profile ones with Julianne Hough and Shayna Taylor, gave no clues to the identity of his fiancée. But as the whispers about his engagement grow louder, fans are left scrambling for any hint of who this mystery woman might be.

The big reveal began when Ryan casually teased something exciting on his show, On Air with Ryan Seacrest. With a knowing smile, he dropped a cryptic message about “big things coming,” causing Kelly Ripa to cheekily jab at him about potential rings. The playful banter didn’t stop there—sources say Ryan has been spotted at Tiffany & Co. in Los Angeles, shopping for diamond bands. Fans on social media quickly picked up on the clues and began to speculate wildly. “Ryan’s too smooth to stay single,” one fan tweeted, while another exclaimed, “Could it be a co-star?”

Despite his past with famous faces, Ryan’s current love interest doesn’t seem to fit the usual Hollywood mold. This is someone he’s known “forever but never dated,” according to a friend of the star. The engagement is described as a complete surprise, especially since the bride has stayed far away from the spotlight, unlike his famous exes. She’s “his rock,” says an insider, someone who is private, grounded, and fiercely loyal to him. This twist in Ryan’s romantic life has raised eyebrows across the entertainment world, with fans eagerly trying to figure out who the bride is.

Could it be someone unexpected from the world of reality TV? Ryan has been involved with Keeping Up with the Kardashians for years, producing the hit reality show that catapulted the Kardashian-Jenner family into superstardom. Imagine Kris Jenner as his mother-in-law—that would certainly make for some interesting holiday dinners! Or maybe this romance has been blooming for years under the radar, perhaps sparked during the glitz and glam of New Year’s Rockin’ Eve celebrations in Times Square? Sources hint that Ryan’s fiancée is someone who has remained out of the public eye, and her connection with him is one that has been years in the making.

When it comes to wedding plans, think nothing less than extravagant. While exact details remain scarce, insiders suggest that Ryan is pulling out all the stops for his wedding day. Picture this: a chartered yacht off the coast of Santorini, or a luxurious celebration at the Plaza Hotel in New York, complete with an A-list guest list. The man known for juggling an 18-hour workday might finally slow down and enjoy a well-deserved honeymoon glow

Fans are absolutely losing it over this unexpected news. “Ryan Seacrest settling down? I need pics!” one tweet demanded, while another begged, “Tell us the bride’s name!” Seacrest’s Southern roots, growing up in Atlanta, could point to a classic Southern belle as the bride. Or perhaps his Los Angeles lifestyle suggests the mystery woman could be a media maven, someone from his industry. The mystery surrounding his fiancée has left fans on edge, eagerly awaiting any new hints.

Despite the buzz, Ryan remains tight-lipped. He’s mastered the art of deflecting rumors and steering clear of public romantic speculation over the years. However, this time, the veil is starting to lift, and fans are more than ready for the big reveal. Could it be someone from his past who’s stepping into the spotlight? Or is this a new Hollywood love story that no one could have predicted?

As 2025 continues to heat up, fans and Hollywood insiders alike are glued to every hint, every detail that could lead them to the identity of Ryan Seacrest’s fiancée. With the mystery surrounding his engagement only growing, we can’t help but wonder: Who is the woman who has finally captured the heart of the man who’s been the “busiest man in Hollywood” for decades?

Stay tuned as we continue to unravel the story behind Ryan Seacrest’s surprise engagement, and keep checking back for updates on this star-studded wedding that’s guaranteed to keep us guessing until the very end.