As HBO finalizes its cast for the highly anticipated Harry Potter television series, reports indicate that Paapa Essiedu is in the final stages of negotiations to portray Professor Severus Snape, according to Deadline.

The news has triggered a wave of online debate, with reactions ranging from concerns about book accuracy to broader cultural and political discourse.

One of the primary concerns among fans is that Essiedu’s appearance differs significantly from Snape’s original description in J.K. Rowling’s books. The character is depicted as a pale-skinned man with greasy black hair, a hooked nose, and yellow, uneven teeth. Some fans argue that Essiedu, known for Gangs of London and I May Destroy You, is too conventionally attractive for the role. There is speculation that heavy makeup or prosthetics might be used to bridge the gap, a move many view as unnecessary or forced.

Beyond physical resemblance, fans are also debating how Essiedu’s casting might affect key character dynamics. Snape’s backstory—particularly his tense relationship with James Potter—has raised concerns about how bullying scenes involving a young Black Snape could be interpreted. Critics say this could introduce unintended racial undertones that shift the original narrative’s intent.

The backlash also feeds into larger culture-war narratives. Some critics argue the casting reflects a “DEI agenda”, accusing Hollywood of race-swapping characters to signal progressive values. Others suggest it may be an attempt by Warner Bros. to appeal to liberal audiences who have distanced themselves from the franchise due to J.K. Rowling’s comments on transgender issues.

Despite the controversy, industry observers believe the backlash is unlikely to deter mainstream viewers. Still, with many major roles yet to be revealed, the series appears headed for a long road of scrutiny as it attempts to reimagine one of the most iconic franchises of the modern era.