The American Idol Season 23 finale crowned Jamal Roberts as the winner on May 18, 2025 — but the announcement has stirred a firestorm of debate among fans, many of whom were rooting for runner-up John Foster.

Despite record-breaking viewership and a historic 26 million votes, the finale ended on a polarizing note, with the outcome — and even the judges — facing heavy scrutiny online.

Jamal Roberts Wins, But John Foster Fans Cry Foul

In a celebratory Facebook post shared by American Idol, Roberts was pictured beaming while holding his daughters and a winner’s hamper. But rather than unity, the post triggered a wave of frustration from fans who believed Foster deserved the crown.

Across Instagram and Facebook, comments flooded in:

“John should have won. He was so natural.”
“Another rigged season.”
“Jamal screams too much — John was robbed.”
“I won’t watch next season. Foster deserved better.”

While some expressed support for Roberts, others argued that Foster’s country authenticity, songwriting talent, and consistent performances made him the true star of the season.

Interestingly, a few viewers even saw a silver lining:
“Now John Foster isn’t bound to an American Idol contract.”

Carrie Underwood’s Guest Judge Role Draws Mixed Reactions

The controversy didn’t stop with the winner announcement. During the Top 5 Disney Night episode on May 12, Carrie Underwood’s guest judging role received criticism from viewers who accused her of showing favoritism — particularly against Jamal Roberts.

Underwood dressed as Rapunzel in a dramatic purple gown, complete with a thigh-high slit, silver heels, and a long braid accented with flowers. While the look drew some compliments, many fans were more focused on her critiques.

Some of the harshest feedback included:

“Get rid of her. Her bias is showing.”
“I wish there was a way to vote her off.”
“Why so hard on Jamal? He’s amazing.”
“Jelly Roll please, she’s got to go!”

Others defended the country superstar, writing:

“You’re still going to get criticized, so might as well do whatever you want!”
“I loved you as a judge. Hope you come back next year.”

Disney Night Recap: The Songs That Decided the Top 3

The Disney-themed episode narrowed the field to the final three: John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Breanna Nix.

Here’s what they performed:

John Foster: “The Bare Necessities” (The Jungle Book), “Rainbow Connection” (The Muppet Movie)
Jamal Roberts: “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough” (Remember the Titans), “Beauty and the Beast”
Breanna Nix: “This Will Be (An Everlasting Love)” (The Parent Trap), “You’ll Be in My Heart” (Tarzan)

Eliminated that night were Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis.

Final Thoughts: A Divisive Season That Still Delivered

With Jamal Roberts crowned the winner, and John Foster emerging as a fan favorite, American Idol Season 23 leaves behind a legacy of passionate fandom, outstanding performances, and memorable drama.